Catrice Clean ID & Full Satin Nude lipstick review

catrice lipstick review swatch lipswatch clean id ultra high shine full satin nude fair skin makeup look application

In today’s blog post we are going for a double whammy: a video AND a picture blog all in one. The reason? To show you the closeups and application of the new lipsticks from Catrice’s 2020 fall/ winter update. They released two new lines: the Clean ID Ultra High Shine and the Full Satin Nud lipsticks. There was one more lipstick that was released, which was a red shade from their already existing Demi Matt line in REDefine Love. I already reviewed that lipstick for you here. Let’s have a closer look at all these lovely nude lipsticks.

Review: Catrice Clean ID Ultra High Shine lipstick & Full Satin Nude lipstick

Products mentioned:

  • Catrice Clean ID Ultra High Shine lipstick 010 True Color
  • Catrice Clean ID Ultra High Shine lipstick 020 Peachy
  • Catrice Clean ID Ultra High Shine lipstick 030 Make It Nuder
  • Catrice Clean ID Ultra High Shine lipstick 040 Nude Beach
  • Catrice Clean ID Ultra High Shine lipstick 060 Thank Nude Next
  • Catrice Full Satin Nude lipstick 010 Full of Braveness
  • Catrice Full Satin Nude lipstick 020 Full of Strength
  • Catrice Full Satin Nude lipstick 030 Full of Attitude
  • Catrice Full Satin Nude lipstick 040 Full of Courage
  • Catrice Full Satin Nude lipstick 050 Full of Boldness

Catrice Clean ID Ultra High Shine lipstick

catrice lipstick review swatch lipswatch clean id ultra high shine full satin nude fair skin makeup look application
catrice lipstick review swatch lipswatch clean id ultra high shine full satin nude fair skin makeup look application
catrice lipstick review swatch lipswatch clean id ultra high shine full satin nude fair skin makeup look application

As you can see these lipsticks are creamy and have shine to them, but I found that the shine is caused by shimmer rather than the formula itself. In fact after a first swatch most of that shimmer had disappeared save for a bit in one shade and so these were no longer as shiny. As you will see in the video and the swatch pictures below, out of all of these only looks okay on me. While a nice formula that needs quite a bit of touching up, I didn’t think the undertones of these lipstick shades were quite right for me.

Catrice Full Satin Nude lipstick

catrice lipstick review swatch lipswatch clean id ultra high shine full satin nude fair skin makeup look application
catrice lipstick review swatch lipswatch clean id ultra high shine full satin nude fair skin makeup look application
catrice lipstick review swatch lipswatch clean id ultra high shine full satin nude fair skin makeup look application

These are the Full Satin Nude lipsticks. There already is a line of Full Satin lipsticks and those are some great creamy lipsticks with a satin finish that have a pretty okay wear time. Again, like with the Clean ID range the undertones of these were not quite right for me save for the deepest shade. The others were either too pale or too warm toned. So these are not the best if you have a cool to neutral undertone and fair skin lik me.

Closeup of the lip swatches

catrice lipstick review swatch lipswatch clean id ultra high shine full satin nude fair skin makeup look application
Catrice Clean ID Ultra High Shine lipstick 010 True Color
catrice lipstick review swatch lipswatch clean id ultra high shine full satin nude fair skin makeup look application
Catrice Clean ID Ultra High Shine lipstick 020 Peachy
catrice lipstick review swatch lipswatch clean id ultra high shine full satin nude fair skin makeup look application
Catrice Clean ID Ultra High Shine lipstick 030 Make It Nuder
Catrice Clean ID Ultra High Shine lipstick 040 Nude Beach
catrice lipstick review swatch lipswatch clean id ultra high shine full satin nude fair skin makeup look application
Catrice Clean ID Ultra High Shine lipstick 060 Thank Nude Next
catrice lipstick review swatch lipswatch clean id ultra high shine full satin nude fair skin makeup look application
Catrice Full Satin Nude lipstick 010 Full of Braveness
catrice lipstick review swatch lipswatch clean id ultra high shine full satin nude fair skin makeup look application
Catrice Full Satin Nude lipstick 020 Full of Strength
catrice lipstick review swatch lipswatch clean id ultra high shine full satin nude fair skin makeup look application
Catrice Full Satin Nude lipstick 030 Full of Attitude
catrice lipstick review swatch lipswatch clean id ultra high shine full satin nude fair skin makeup look application
Catrice Full Satin Nude lipstick 040 Full of Courage
catrice lipstick review swatch lipswatch clean id ultra high shine full satin nude fair skin makeup look application
Catrice Full Satin Nude lipstick 050 Full of Boldness

My Final Thoughts

What do I think of these two new lines of lipsticks? Well, to be quite fair I prefer the Full Satin Nude over the Clean ID Ultra High Shine but that’s not saying much. In both lines I felt that the creamy texture is really nice and while that never makes for a super longlasting lipstick, it certainly makes for a comfortable one. However, in both lines I also feel there are too many shades I just wouldn’t wear as they aren’t right for my complexion. Out of all 10 shades featured here today there are only 2 I am considering keeping.

Would I recommend the new Catrice lipsticks for fall/ winter 2020?

I am not saying you should stay away from these as from a quality stand point I think these are fine. Not great, but they will get the job done if you are looking for an affordable lipsticks that doesn’t break the bank. That does mean thought that you will only be able to make this work for you if you find a shade that suits you. In my case there were very few and I also felt that the shades looks a bit different between the bullet, the swatch and on the lips. It would be best if you can find testers in store and swatch them on your lips but that is of course currently very difficult to do.

Which shade would be your pick?

2 Comments Add yours

  1. Great post! I tried Catrice lipsticks and for some reason it went on patchy which sucks. On you, these colors look great especially with your eye look. I love the colors you used.

    1. indiequeen84 says:

      Their ranges really differ in how they work and apply. Most of my favorites have long been discontinued.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.